No, it's not rolling because Squeeze will soon be not rolling. That's partially why #! Statler is still labeled Alpha, because Squeeze hasn't been released.
The #! that I'm currently using is Statler r20101205, not Alpha2 neither of which are new versions. When Squeeze is released Crunchbang will be based on Wheezy and Statler may become Waldorf. http://crunchbanglinux.org/forums/topic/10418/crunchbang-10-statler-r20101205/page/5/
It seems that the consensus now is that Statler may go stable, so I guess you were right. I have changed my sources list to testing and disabled the Statler repository to avoid any conflicts.